View source

From Theopedia

You do not have permission to edit this page, for the following reason:

You can view and copy the source of this page:

'''Neo-Orthodoxy''' is best described as "an approach or attitude that began in a common environment but soon expressed itself in diverse ways. It began in the crisis associated with the disillusionment following World War I, with a rejection of Protestant [[scholasticism]], and with a denial of the Protestant [[liberalism|liberal]] movement which had stressed accommodation of Christianity to Western science and culture, the [[immanence of God]], and the progressive improvement of mankind." <ref> R. V. Schnucker, Elwell Evangelical Dictionary, [http://mb-soft.com/believe/txc/neoortho.htm Neo-Orthodoxy].</ref> __TOC__ Notable figures associated with this form of theology include [[Emil Brunner]] (1889-1966) and [[Paul Tillich]] (1886-1965) whose theological methods were markedly influenced by the writings of Danish philosopher [[Soren Kierkegaard]] (1813-1855) who is regarded as the father of [[existentialism]]. Some scholars have added [[Karl Barth]] (1886-1968) to the list, but this has been recently disputed. <ref> [[Bruce McCormack]] has argued that the term "neo-orthodox" is inappropriate for Barth and that such a label is actually the result of Anglo-American neo-orthodox readings of him. See his work, ''Karl Barth's Critically Realistic Dialectical Theology: Its Genesis and Development 1909-1936'' (Oxford, 1997), esp. pp. 24-28. </ref> Neo-Orthodoxy, in fact, is known for its existential element which stresses the subjective experience of the individual and regards propositional [[truth]] as either irrelevant or indeterminate. According to Neo-Orthodoxy, existential truth is a truth that transforms the individual in his concrete here and now. Propositional truth, on the other hand, may increase one's information but leaves man essentially unchanged. According to the Neo-Orthodox, as long as we conceive of [[the Fall]] as an historical event, we fail to think existentially. They typically see the Fall as something we all commit. The [[Bible]] is said to contain within it an inspired witness, but it is a mistake to directly identify Scripture as the Word of God; [[Jesus]], the person, is the Word of God. The Bible can become the Word of God only when God chooses to ''use'' it to reveal himself. Therefore, the actual text and words of Scripture are not identified as the Word of God. Rather, it is an instrument to communicate and witness to the true Word, Jesus. Neo-Orthodoxy accepts [[Biblical criticism|higher criticism]] of the Scriptures but believes [[exegesis]] must move beyond mere historical inquiries. ==American Neo-orthodoxy== Neo-orthodoxy is an umbrella term for profoundly different theologies. It was embraced in the U.S. by thousands of pastors and theologians who generally received their theology from Brunner and Niebuhr rather than from Barth. American neo-orthodoxy in the 1940s and 1950s typically meant a compound of [[Emil Brunner]]’s dogmatics, [[Reinhold Niebuhr]]’s theological ethics, and the Scripture scholarship of the biblical theology movement. This movement, a reaction to the perceived sterility of earlier, purely analytic studies, emphasized the unifying themes of Scripture and stressed the revelatory acts of God in history as described in the Bible. <ref>Gary Dorrien, [http://www.religion-online.org/showarticle.asp?title=2116 The Origins of Postliberalism].</ref> ==The end of the movement?== The Neo-orthodox movement was stunningly successful in reorienting the field of modern theology. The biblical language of [[sin]], [[Transcendence of God|transcendence]] and the Word of God resumed a prominent place in theological discourse. But in a remarkably brief period of time, the house of neo-orthodoxy crashed. During the 1960s, the theological giants of neo-orthodoxy passed away, James Barr’s claims about the uniqueness of biblical semantics dismantled biblical theology, and Langdon Gilkey exposed the incoherence of neo-orthodox God-language. Gilkey showed that for all of its condemnations of theological liberalism, neo-orthodoxy construed the meaning of the scriptural "mighty acts of God" in essentially liberal terms. Gilkey later called attention to a secularizing trend in theology -- he called it "death-of-God theology" which was led by former Barthians such as William Hamilton and Paul van Buren. Shortly after that, the first currents of liberation theology emerged in Latin America and the U.S., making neo-orthodoxy seem stuffy, provincial and oppressive. <ref>Dorrien, Ibid. </ref> ==A revival of Neo-orthodoxy?== [[Postmodernism]] has proven to be remarkably congenial to neo-orthodoxy as a new generation of theologically conservative clergy and theologians works to find ways to affirm the authority and truth of scripture without viewing it as historically accurate or literally true in all cases. [[Post-liberal]] scholars such as [[George Lindbeck]] and [[Charles Campbell]] are producing new scholarship that, in many ways, is a revival of neo-orthodox understandings of [[Scripture]] and the [[Church]]. == Criticism == === Scripture === While Neo-Orthodoxy claims to hold many of the orthodox [[doctrine]]s of the faith, it radically departs in a critical area - the [[Authority of the Bible|authority]] and [[Inspiration of the Bible|inspiration]] of the Scriptures. Scripture is no longer a reliable guide unless God chooses to use it in a persons life. Hence, it is difficult to find any doctrinal consistency among Neo-Orthodox theologians, even with regard to critical things such as the nature of the [[Atonement of Christ|atonement]]. {{sectionstub}} == Notes == {{reflist}} == References == * ''Baker's Dictionary of Theology'', ed. E. Harrison, (Grand Rapids: Baker Book House, 1960), s.v. "Neo Orthodoxy" == See also == * [[Postliberalism]] ==External links== *[http://mb-soft.com/believe/txc/neoortho.htm An overview from Elwell Evangelical Dictionary] *[http://www.gotquestions.org/neoorthodoxy.html What is Neo-Orthodoxy?] at GotQuestions.com

Return to Neo-Orthodoxy.