Talk:Simon Gathercole

From Theopedia

Is the info a quote? Or is the reference merely to the reivew? JordanBarrett 17:53, 15 November 2005 (EST)

If this still applies, I assume this mainly refers to the following text, which I also thought was unclear:

• Drawn from his dissertation, his book Where is Boasting? (2002) "was a critique of the New Perspective on Paul, and focused on Second-Temple Judaism and Romans 1-5."

It seems to me that the meaning of this is that the book was drawn from his dissertation and then the book is described. If that is the real meaning of it, then perhaps it should be changed to the following:

• His book, Where is Boasting (2002), which was drawn from his dissertation, "was a critique of the New Perspective on Paul, and focused on Second-Temple Judaism and Romans 1-5."

I guess the other possible meaning is that this quote is drawn from his dissertation, in which case the following might be a good choice:

• According to his dissertation, his book Where is Boasting (2002) "was a critique of the New Perspective on Paul, and focused on Second-Temple Judaism and Romans 1-5."

--Whiteknox 15:16, 1 January 2007 (UTC)

Aberdeen page gone

To note, the links provided in the article are now gone since Gathercole moved to Durham. Jordan Barrett (talk) 15:31, 17 September 2007 (UTC)